A Marketer's Guide to Influencer Whitelisting_cover_webp

A Marketer’s Guide to Influencer Whitelisting

You may have heard influencer whitelisting is a hot topic in the influencer marketing world, but what exactly is it? How do you know if whitelisting is the right influencer marketing strategy for your next campaign?  And what social media channels work best for whitelisting content?

Don’t worry, I had lots of questions too. But we’ve got you covered. Here at The Shelf, we’ve done a deep dive on all things influencer whitelisting so you don’t have to. In the following post, we’ll give you all the deets on what whitelisting is, how and when you should use it in your influencer campaigns, some insights into our whitelisting results, and more!

Ready to take your influencer marketing to the next level? Let’s dive in.

What is Influencer Whitelisting?

Pinterest pin - A Marketer's Guide to Influencer whitelisting

First and foremost, let’s define our terms. Whitelisting is a campaign optimization strategy that allows you to turn organic influencer posts into paid ads. The important thing to note about these paid posts is that they are run through the influencer’s account – not your brand account. (This differentiates whitelisting from dark posts, but more on that later.)

By creating paid ads from an influencer’s organic posts, you can increase the reach of your sponsored content. AND you’re able to target your desired audience more accurately.

Whitelisting influencer content also allows you to make each post in your campaign more shoppable.  Clickable CTA buttons are added to each whitelisted post with trackable URLs. That means you can add a “Shop now” or “Learn more” button to content and track exactly how many viewers convert from that post.

You may already be aware that shoppable posts are all the rage right now. Experts project the global market for social commerce will reach $2.9 trillion by 2026 (yes, that’s trillion with a “T”), so it’s time to whitelist that influencer content and get that bread. 🍞

Benefits of Whitelisting Content in Your Influencer Campaigns

If you want to see results on your influencer marketing campaigns, whitelisting is the way to go.  Influencer whitelisting is one of the primary ways to get conversions and sales on your influencer content.

Plus, it’s a win-win for your brand and your influencers since whitelisted influencer content is amplified to wider audiences, giving both the influencer and your product more exposure. More eyeballs on your products mean more opportunities for people to click and buy. And on whitelisted ads, getting to your brand’s website is as easy as clicking the in-post CTA button. Easy peasy!

When you prioritize whitelisting as part of your influencer marketing strategy, you can reach new audiences, find customers you didn’t know you had, and specifically target audiences that would otherwise be unavailable to you.

Influencer whitelisting allows you to:

  • Drive clicks through CTA buttons
  • Run ads at scale (up to 40 per campaign!)
  • Review comprehensive insight reporting
  • Optimize in real-time with the lowest CPM
  • Edit influencer content before putting dollars behind it
  • Target audiences precisely based on your campaign objective
  • Leverage different social media platforms in the same campaign

One of the benefits of whitelisting influencer content is that you have the ability to make edits and tweaks before putting any money behind a post. Take this whitelisted Instagram story from quip for example.

Influencer @luciebfink created a story post for quip’s special edition red toothbrush with the text, “Volume up ✨ to hear what this incredible special edition @getquip will do @red.” (Sidenote: quip has since moved their Instagram account to @quip if you’re reading this and thinking I do need a new toothbrush.)

Quip decided to whitelist the content but made a copy edit to better fit their campaign objective, highlighting their partnership with @red. The new copy read, “@getquip has an amazing new partnership with @red.” This slight edit allowed them to make the brand’s handle center stage in the post and better illuminate the @red partnership.

Tweaks like these allow an even more symbiotic relationship with influencers. Your creators get to create content that serves their followers and you have the ability to make small changes so the language better speaks to your audience within their following. 

Of course, always be sure to outline editing permissions and parameters with your influencers before launching a whitelisting campaign. You’ll want to make sure your influencers feel comfortable and confident in the content that lives under their handle and on their page.

Whitelisting vs Dark Posts vs Boosting

Of course, whitelisting isn’t the only paid optimization strategy. You’ve probably heard of boosting and dark posts. These are good strategies too, but they offer different benefits and parameters than whitelisting. Let’s get into it.

Dark Posts

Dark posts are basically social ads for your brand. You can run them on any social channel and they can be created with brand-produced assets or influencer-produced assets. Unlike boosted, organic, and whitelisted content, they don’t show up on your (or your influencer’s) timeline or organically in your follower’s feeds.

These ads show up as sponsored content to audiences you are specifically targeting. You run these ads through your brand account (not the influencer’s account) and they can be used to compliment boosted or whitelisted posts.

Boosting

Boosting is also known as the handshake tool. It allows influencers to tag your brand using the Branded Content Tool. From there, you can boost the post from the backend of your ads manager. You can also boost posts from your brand account. You can boost an individual post on Facebook or Instagram and “promote” individual videos on TikTok.

Unlike whitelisting, each post must be boosted individually. This makes it harder to scale boosted content on a campaign level. Boosted content is great if you want to highlight a specific piece of content or target different audiences with each post.

 

Chart showing Influencer Whitelisting vs Boosting vs Dark Posts

How to Whitelist on Instagram

Know your platform. Whether you’re using an agency or whitelisting through influencers’ individual pages, your influencers will need to activate their business accounts on both Instagram and Facebook (especially if you intend to whitelist cross-platform). This will allow you to track engagement and complete any necessary (and agreed upon) content edits.

When building a whitelisting campaign on Instagram, think in terms of scalability. Creating content designed for feed posts is one of the most effective ways to ensure content is scalable. Square posts with a 1:1 ratio and vertical posts with a 4:5 ratio work best. Images of these sizes can be repurposed in an Instagram story, Facebook post, or Facebook story.

Going the reels route?  Try to make your video compatible with both Instagram and TikTok viewing so you can get the most mileage out of a single post.

Looking for an Instagram refresher? Check out our Instagram influencer marketing tips and tricks.

Whitelisting phone labels

How to Whitelist on Facebook

If you decide not to partner with an agency or whitelisting platform, you’ll need to go the manual whitelisting route. The first step is to gain access to your influencer’s Facebook Business Manager. Once those permissions are shared, you will be able to access the influencer’s Facebook and Instagram accounts through your brand’s Facebook Ads Manager. From there you will grant your influencer permission to “Create ads” for your brand.

Similar rules apply when it comes to whitelisting under the umbrella of Meta apps. Create content for scalability. Choose influencers you trust. And allow creativity to flow so the paid media doesn’t feel like an ad.

How to Whitelist on TikTok

Creativity is king.

Our Director of Digital Strategy, Anton Nestel, likes to say TikTok is the Super Bowl of influencer marketing – and for good reason. TikTok allows creators and influencers to let their creativity run wild, and it shows in engagement.

Whitelisting is all about repurposing influencer-generated content. The magic of whitelisting is that it makes paid media feel organic. The thing about modern social media users, and especially TikTok scrollers, is that they don’t mind seeing branded content, but they don’t want to see ads. At least not in the traditional sense. Whitelisting influencer content can allow your brand to land in the sweet spot of getting the most bang for your buck and not putting off viewers.

Finding influencers you trust on TikTok, whose audiences align with yours is one of the best ways to spend your whitelisting budget. The trick is to allow your influencers to create the content in the way they want to. (That’s why choosing the right influencers is so important.) Embrace paying for content that feels organic to your audience.

The proof is in the pudding. We’ve been getting some pretty exciting engagement stats back from our clients’ whitelisted influencer content. We’re talking as much as 12 percent engagement on whitelisted TikTok posts (compared to — still respectable — 2 percent engagement on other platforms).

Influencer Whitelisting Best Practices

Now that you know a bit about the benefits of whitelisting influencer content, it’s time to start building your next campaign. When it comes to influencer marketing best practices, we’ve got you covered. Here are our top tips when looking to reach your target audience with whitelisted influencer-generated content.

1. Encourage creativity.

Let your influencers unleash their creativity. Of course, you want their posts to fit your brand and the objective of the campaign, but try your best not to stifle their creativity. Whitelisted influencer content gets the most engagement when it still feels authentic and organic.

2. Don’t let a small budget deter you.

The good news is you don’t have to have a huge budget to have a pretty decent impact with your whitelisting. We recommend you set aside at least 10 percent of your campaign budget for whitelisting. Here at The Shelf, we use the creator platform Lumanu to whitelist our customers’ campaigns.

If you’re a small or medium-sized brand, that isn’t working with the right influencer marketing agency (like The Shelf), don’t fret. Whitelisting will deliver results even if you don’t have a lot to spend. 

3. Choose the right influencers.

Select a few creators you trust and have a consistent relationship with. We recommend focusing on a few special influencers who have more of an ambassadorial role with your brand. Invest a couple hundred dollars in each influencers’ content for the campaign. Then you can run the whitelisted content directly through their page.

4. Extend the shelf life of your influencer marketing campaign.

Take a look at the scope of your campaign. In a traditional ad group, you’d want at least two to three ads up and running at a time. The same principle applies here. Wait to start your influencer whitelisting until two or three posts are live. Take the time to assess engagement and make any necessary tweaks before rolling out the rest of the campaign.

Once you’ve given the first few posts the chance to simmer, go ahead and start whitelisting that content and any future content that is part of the campaign. A good rule of thumb is to continue whitelisting on a campaign until two weeks after the last piece of content is posted. This allows the content to have as much time to run as possible.

5. Whitelist as much content as possible.

When it comes to influencer whitelisting, more is more. We’ve found that the top-performing organic posts don’t always align with the top-performing paid posts (even when those paid posts feel organic). So the age-old advice of putting dollars behind your best-performing content doesn’t work as well here.

We recommend whitelisting as much content as possible and letting the results speak for themselves. And hey, with the capacity to whitelist as many as 40 posts per campaign, why wouldn’t you take advantage of that reach?

6. Know your rights.

When working directly from an influencer’s business account, it’s more important than ever to know your content rights. Make sure you establish the following with your influencers upfront:

  • Content ownership
  • Guidelines for reuse
  • Payment terms and fees
  • Duration of the campaign
  • All channels used in the campaign
  • Modification permissions (including edits)
  • How your brand can repurpose the content
  • Content posting schedule and requirements
  • Any restrictions or exclusivity for influencer social activity

Conclusion: Make the Most of Your Influencer Marketing Campaigns with The Shelf

All that is to say, influencer whitelisting is a pretty rad optimization strategy for influencer marketing campaigns. It allows you to grow your audience, strengthen relationships with your best influencers, and increase engagement across multiple platforms at once.

Looking for more influencer marketing tactics or help whitelisting your next influencer campaign?  We’ve put together thousands of successful social media strategies for EPIC influencer campaigns for brands just like yours. We’d love to make your whitelisting dreams a reality. Click below to schedule a demo.

Social proof is a powerful way for brands to

Gain their customers' trust.

Our campaign strategists work with our sales team + your in-house team to dream up multiple creative, fun, on-brand concepts for your influencer campaign. This way, your campaign not only reaches a bunch of people and gets engagement, you also end up with a catalog of really, REALLy great marketing assets that you can reuse across your own branded channels to build your value and boost your rep with your customers.

Want to spitball a few ideas? 👇

Schedule a Strategy Call

Close

#

Ready to run your next campaign?

Make me famous

I want clicks