Menu Close
colorful line illustration of people on their phones, shopping, and measuring ROI - conversion campaigns

Influencer Marketing for Conversions vs Influencer Marketing for Awareness

By far, the outcome our brand clients are most focused on in the current market is sales. They want The Shelf team to put together influencer marketing campaigns for conversions by partnering them with creators who truly can influence purchasing decisions.

Despite everyone needing brand awareness and visibility before being able to get a sale, brand awareness campaigns aren’t typically the sole focus of influencer activations. Stakeholders are pushing marketing teams to make it rain. đź’°đź’°


But we get that without understanding the nuances, it can be tough to figure out how to structure a campaign to boost awareness vs structuring an influencer marketing for conversions. So, let’s talk that – the difference between top-of-the-funnel influencer campaigns vs bottom-of-the-funnel influencer campaigns.

TOFU Influencer Campaigns vs BOFU Influencer Campaigns

If you’re of the mindset that influencer marketing is just for boosting brand awareness, or you happen to be one of the people who low-key think a brand awareness campaign is a cop-out, this post is for you. Influencer campaigns can play a really important role in ultimately helping you to turn eyeballs into sales. Of course, there are more elements to factor into your omni-channel sales strategy than just having influencers tell their followers that our product is the cat’s meow (and the dog’s bow-wow), but understanding how to structure influencer campaigns to support and even facilitate the sales process is pretty important these days.

Let’s quickly identify a couple of important things that distinguish a brand awareness campaign from a campaign for traffic and clicks. 


Whether you’re rolling out a brand awareness influencer campaign or a campaign for clicks, reach is going to be important. 

For brand lift influencer campaigns… it’s smart to partner with larger influencers – as many as your budget can handle. The goal is to have a network of macro-influencers talking up your product or brand to their followers and extolling the virtues of your product.

When your campaign goal is to get clicks… partner with a diverse set of influencers who have sizable, engaged followings. In this case, it may be more beneficial to enlist a greater number of smaller influencers to give you the opportunity to target different segments of your audience with more targeted messaging.


For brand lift influencer campaigns… Short-form video is fantastic for boosting awareness, which makes TikTok, Instagram (Reels) and even YouTube (Short) are the perfect platforms for getting more eyes. YouTube is effective, for sure, but it tends to be a much larger financial investment (like, add-a-zero larger).  

For influencer campaigns for conversions… Coupling Instagram Reels with YouTube is a great way to have influencer content perform double duty. If you’re driving people to a landing page, you could have influencers push traffic to their own blogs where users can grab coupon codes after checking out more behind-the-scenes content on the brand or product. You could also have influencers send traffic directly to your own landing page by making it a requirement for influencers to attach a specific, trackable URL to their posts.  

When they’re active on their own blogs, the content they create for your campaign has a much better chance of surfacing in Google search results. When they’re also active on Instagram, they can drive traffic from the platform to their blog, or from the platform to your landing/product page. 

Another thing to remember about blogs is that the content has an exponentially longer life cycle than Instagram posts (2 years compared to 2 days). So, you want to partner with bloggers who have blogs that are well-trafficked, and whose blogs bring in unique monthly visitors in the tens of thousands. You may have to work with them to create keyword-optimized influencer-generated blog content

Dedicated Content

For brand awareness campaigns… One of the things brands can do to minimize costs is to include their products as part of a larger piece of content that may include other products as well. For instance, having your luxury bath set included in a Mother’s Day haul video that features super-comfy slippers, aromatherapy set, and a few other luxe items. 

Great for brand awareness. Not ideal for clicks. 

For an influencer marketing conversion campaign… When the goal is to get clicks, have influencers create dedicated content to ensure your product is the only one featured. For Instagram posts, also make sure your branded hashtag and your brand or product @-mentions are the only ones in the caption. For YouTube videos, make sure your link is the only one in the product section of the video description. 

For brand awareness influencer campaigns… mentions are 100% necessary, but links usually aren’t. It may even be too soon in the process to expect people to hop over to your site from IG unless your product is being tagged or included among shoppable items as part of a lookbook or outfit of the day kind of thing. But generally, for brand lift influencer campaigns (which can live on Instagram), you just want to make sure the influencer includes the branded campaign hashtag and @-mentions the brand. 

For an influencer marketing campaign for conversions… you’ll need both links and a CTA. This one and the previous point go hand-in-hand because you’ll want a dedicated post that makes your product look like the only game in town. You don’t want the influencer mentioning competitors by name, even if it’s just to say how awesome your thing is compared to theirs. And you don’t want your link buried in a list of affiliate products that could easily steal your thunder. 

No, to get conversions, have influencer partners include links back to your landing page/product page, and the swipe-up feature in Stories should go to your landing page or product page as well.

Love this example from a campaign we ran for Feit Electric, which generated more than 60,000 clicks over to our client’s landing pages. The campaign called for several influencers to drive traffic to Feit’s website. So, landing pages were created of each influencer’s recommendations (to match the products they created their content around) and traffic was driven to these landing pages from sponsored content posted on TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube.

Angela Lanter created this back porch makeover video 👇🏽, transitioning their porch from a fall theme to a winter theme using Feit Electric string lights.

She attached links from her content to a corresponding landing page on Feit’s website, which included those string lights as one of her recommendations.

Angelas pics for Feit campaign

It’s so important that when people see influencer content they have a clear path for what they should do next. “Swipe up to grab this deal” or “Head over to my blog for the coupon code” or Links and a clear CTA will help influencers drive Instagram traffic from Instagram and provide followers with those next important steps.

In this case, Angela included trackable links in the description of her YouTube video and she actually walked users through the Feit Electric app that allows you to control your smart lights even when you’re not home.

One thing on pushing traffic to a landing page…

Now, I’ll quickly add here that a Wunderman Thompson poll revealed that 56 percent of consumers would rather not have to leave a platform to make a purchase. So, for your 2023 clicks-focused influencer campaigns, it may be worth it to consider focusing more on streamlining and shortening the path to purchase. 

Charts social comerce and shoppable posts
Source: Wunderman Thompson’s The Future Shopper Report 2022 (gated)

Promo Codes + Pixels

For brand awareness campaigns… pixels are a good idea because looping retargeting into your brand awareness campaign is a smart move. I always like to use the vitamin example. Let me first say that I’m not really in the market for a new vitamin since I’m all stocked up and have my regular vitamin on autoship through Amazon. But I actually could be swayed if @getupwithnards or another one of the moms I follow online . This would be one of the influencers I follow who has young children and a full-time job sitch. If one of them finds a vitamin that cures “mom brain” and helps stabilize energy, my ears would perk up, and I promise you it wouldn’t take long before I was in somebody’s funnel.

Unless I got distracted by life. That happens to a lot of us.

And if there’s no retargeting strategy that pulls me back in with a pic of the vitamin bottle or some UGC from a mommy influencer who participated in the campaign, it would be really easy for that vitamin brand that had me HOOKED to miss out on a guaranteed sale. So, pixels are a must for brand awareness campaigns AND conversion campaigns.

But for getting clicks… promo codes also matter. They incentivize the deal you’re promoting, and they’re a good way to track which influencers are delivering for your campaign. When you know that, you know which influencers to loop in for the next stage of your current campaign, and even for future campaigns. 

Product Visibility

For any influencer campaign you run, the images should be hi-res images that are captivating and engagement-worthy. This one isn’t really a differentiator, but it’s worth noting in this post that contextual product embeds will trump basic product placement posts every single time. If I had to nail it down to a percentage, I would say the product should be visible in 20% – 25% of your content, whether that’s video or images. What goes in the rest of the content? LIFE, man!

That’s not to say every post has to be some lame pic of you mopping your floor with a yellow container of cleaning solution on the countertop in the background. (Actually, those don’t have to be lame either.) But it is to say that generally speaking, the actual products won’t be the main focus of the post.

A really fun take on this may be hosting an Instagram takeover where each of your influencer partners engage on your profile for a few days as part of the campaign. But still, all that other stuff I mentioned still applies.

Content + Messaging

The final aspect of this whole thing that is important for both brand awareness campaigns and campaigns for conversions is the messaging. Remember what I said earlier about not needing vitamins, but being swayed by a mom who feels my pain and maybe has a better solution than me taking three different types of vitamin every day?

Messaging matters, and that’s true even when it seems like drumming up interest and getting conversions is going to be impossible. Enter Mint Mobile.

Before Deadpool was showing up in Mint Mobile spots with his dry wit and hilarious commentary, Mint Mobile took to Instagram with an influencer campaign to boost brand lift while simultaneously driving clicks. The video below is from Ryan Reynolds’ YouTube channel. His Mint Mobile spots are hilarious.

Our challenge, of course, was getting a SIM card to make you stop-scroll and click. And posting a pic of an actual SIM card wasn’t going to do it. The influencers we brought into the campaign needed to be creative. They needed to be really good at creating compelling visuals.

The other thing was the messaging had to be spot-on if the campaign was going to compel people to click the link and give the service a shot.

Of the concepts we went with for this campaign, I want to show you two so that you can see how content + messaging + product placement works to drive a click.

Concept #1: Influencing (@afashionnerd)

Appeals to influencers and creators, many of whom are building their businesses and reputations while trying to keep their cost of living low.

screenshot of Instagram post from @afashionnerd for Mint Mobile

Concept #2: Adulting(@prettylittleeegirls)

Young adults who are just making their way in the world. What’s more appealing than finally adulting and not needing your parents for something as important as your phone because you’ve found a way to get your phone bill down to $15 a month… and you can definitely handle $15 a month.

screenshot of Instagram post for Mint Mobile by @prettylittleeegirls

This campaign drove more than 10,000 clicks because it wasn’t just pictures of the Mint SIM card and captions talking about it being $15. The campaign was made up of really interesting images that stand out in the feed captioned with messaging that was relatable and that could compel people to act.

This brings me to my final point…

When you’re running a campaign for clicks, make sure you have stipulations in your contract that ensure influencers will keep their posts live for as long as possible. Many influencers don’t mind keeping sponcon in their feeds, but be prepared to negotiate if you want to keep that content live in the influencers’ feeds after your campaign ends. It IS a good idea to keep that cotnent live for as long as you possibly can, ESPECIALLY blog content because once it’s live, it has SEO value that can drive traffic to landing pages for years to come.

So… You CAN Build an Influencer Campaign That Supports Conversions

Effective influencer campaigns go way beyond just building brand awareness. Don’t get me wrong, campaigns designed to boost brand lift are important -awareness always precedes a click – but when you know what to do, you can build influencer campaigns to achieve a number of different marketing goals. Clicks happens to be one of them.

Actually, if you want more help with this, we wrote a book on setting campaign goals here.

Otherwise, The Shelf team is pretty awesome. We dream up amazing concepts to help even the most utilitarian products – like SIM cards – come off as a little more hip, edgy, and necessary. If you need help with your next campaign, we’ve got you covered. Click the button and let’s rack up a win.

Sorilbran Stone Content Strategist

About This Author

Sorilbran Stone | Content Strategist

I serve as the resident content strategist and the official Head of Content Marketing at The Shelf. Marketing is my happy place. I’m as happy looking at analytics as I am actually creating a thing. I focus a lot on dreaming up and implementing the best ways to create, publish, and distribute content that will build your brand and get your audience to do a thing.


Likes are great.

Clicks are better.

Influencer marketing is a powerful strategy for boosting brand awareness, but after that, you need a plan for identifying purchase intent and getting conversions. We can help you with that. The Shelf team builds full-funnel influencer marketing strategies that integrate seamless into your existing digital marketing strategies. Mic-drop behavior, we know.

If you measure success in clicks and not just Likes, you're in the right place.

Schedule a Strategy Call



Ready to run your next campaign?

Make me famous

I want clicks